Update – 13 Nov 2012 – At sometime in october 2012, one of my friends reached out for a job in java world. I tried out linkedin echochamber. Only few friends responded but surprisingly linked in could not guess the question in the post and redirect interested folks to me? I would have expected that linked-in showing how my question/ask for help has reached x people who might be interested and I should connect with them or they having option to send back automatic requests for information/job advertisements. I personally think linked in is the most data driven company for very specific need and they can and will overcome that barrier.
Update – 23 OCt 2012 – One more thread on Facebook Bangalore foodies indicates “need for social site monitoring and effective monetization” . There is two fold possibility. Sensing Contributor statement as question or comment – push relevant stuff to him/her. When just viewer comes in & spends active time on thread – push stuff to him in near real time with relevance. “Refrigerator with deal x” located y km from where you are :).
Update- 6 July 2012 – There is SearchBuddy – MSR research project which talks about “embedded bot kind of service” to identify & answer questions. It is little sparse on how, time span limit, relevance quality.
I follow a group for my interests (what else – but food) - http://www.facebook.com/groups/BLRfoodies/ on facebook. It is pretty active, honest community and I respect the folks who spend time here.
First is a specific food suggestion -
Next is the generic ask for a good location for large bunch of people
Following is a very specific ask about getting herb(seeds/plants) from specific locations
Now the generic advertisements which are thrown when I am looking at that page
One has to respect FB(Mark), Twitter(revenue guy) for accepting they do not know yet what to do. There are folks like bloomreach/reclabs who are trying to bring relevance for merchants. Just how does one surface context sensitive piece based on who is the person? Search is easy – you are looking for information.
But just browsing – wall, timeline – there are chances that some of these you explore. Some of them you ignore. Main issue is kind of information one shares/looks for in each of the networks. Then offcourse one has linkedIn(which should buy stackoverflow) which many folks keep segregated and others aggressively integrate and send same information everywhere. Quora is extremely high value site where people who are part of the network add that “dash” by providing real answers. Each one of them serves different need.
Apart from segregation of “interest” – major issue is trust – search engines are explicit – they sell our intent probability. But moment fb/twitter start doing something which voilates that trust – people might switch back to closed network – phone call/email.
Personally I have never clicked on ads. Ever.